Early-stage credit facilities can be vulnerable to any number of complications and challenges, depending on how aggressive leadership is and where the level of risk tolerance lies.
Though the “perfect” balance varies by industry and specific company KPIs, there are a few key ways to navigate options and improve outcomes.
That’s where Jillian Murrish, CEO of Pier Asset Management, lends a hand. From niche markets to secondary markets, Murrish and her firm are making waves in the early-stage credit facility space, with a focus on targeting less liquid and underserved areas.
She is no stranger to leading the charge and delivering high-impact solutions—and it’s as much about understanding what not to do as it is about knowing what to do.
How early-stage originators differentiate from mature originators and why it matters
Earlier-stage loan originators require a significantly different credit facility product than large, mature originators.
What does that mean from a company priority standpoint?
“Early stage originators — the priority for their credit facility should be that it preserves flexibility, optionality, and has ease of operational use when you're an early stage originator focusing on growth in those early credit cohorts,” Murrish said.
The operational friction a larger, more structured facility can bring or obtain, can create more significant challenges than a lower cost of capital would make worth the trouble.
Cost of capital at an earlier size isn't as important as other factors, such as:
- Growth
- Proof of concept
- Credit quality
“Larger return originators really care about the cost of capital for a good reason, and it starts becoming a profit center for them,” Murrish said. “Whereas early stage — that's not the focus, being in the trenches building that capital markets practice from 40 million to three-quarters of a billion.”
More structured and sophisticated facilities created risk on both sides for being more structured, making the outcome from early stage to mature originator a different product based on those differences in priority.
Why early-stage originators should avoid using expensive equity capital to fund loans
For early-stage originators who are on the starting line of building a product, with zero-originated loans — no loans that have gone through the pipes yet — the most typical funding source is equity capital.
“Maybe the firm has raised a few million dollars of equity capital, they're using that to build out their tech in their infrastructure, and borrower acquisition channels, and then they reserved maybe $500,000 for that first cohort of loans,” Murrish said.
This approach can cause undue stress on the young company, bringing it to a high-pressure start.
“Other founders — which I think is a smart move — will go out to either friends and family, or I've also seen the Venture Partners personally do this, where they'll give $100,000-$200,000 unsecured promissory note to the operating company,” Murrish said. “And the intended purpose is to be used to fund loans.”
Murrish implores early-stage facilities to ask two main questions when considering loan funding options:
- How much have you originated?
- Is there a performance indication?
“Can you show month-over-month performance and show a similar loan product that has a longer credit history, that you can show your performance curve against, and start giving a picture of what performance is going to look like?” She continued.
Ensuring there is as complete of a picture as possible will help dictate what the best next steps look like, and avoid or mitigate unnecessary risks.
One of the most common mistakes early-stage credit facilities make (and what to do instead)
One of the chief mistakes Murrish sees in early-stage credit facilities is making operations too complex, too early.
The more complicated the funding source and funding structure are early on, the more pitfalls are likely to materialize.
“The simpler, the better — trying to use one funding source instead of many, keeping the structures light, etc. That's why the promissory note suggestion for the 500k to a million dollar first part of the loan book is very simple in structure,” Murrish said. “There aren't many covenants you could trip or mistakes you can make in how you manage that capital.”
The promissory note suggestion in Murrish and her firm's loan book even provides a charter of what a facility can do with the money. But beyond that, it's a light touch.
“I'm trying to keep things simple for what is the simplest stage of your business,” she continued.
There are two main ways to avoid over-complicating operations and lean towards sustained growth:
- Hold onto optionality — don’t lock into a deal that could drastically limit your choices
- Prioritize flexibility — maintain a level of flow as the facility grows to ensure quick pivots
“Maybe the $10 million lender signs a three-year deal with a large institutional lender, and they have signed a deal with a very specific loan product,” Murrish said. “And there's no flexibility for criteria in that facility, where if that product no longer works, and they want to do another product or pitch that to the firm, there's not as much flexibility there, and they can end up slowing growth, or being hamstrung entirely.”
Keeping procedures simple as a smaller facility is a crucial key to long-term success, and can shave mountains of stress off of the team and give life to dynamic growth.
Stay tuned for new episodes every other week on the Leaders in Lending Podcast.